Homeowners love improving their homes. That also usually means the board needs to handle a lot of HOA architectural requests. When the process is clear and friendly, projects move smoothly, property values stay protected, and the neighborhood keeps a cohesive look.
What Counts as HOA Architectural Requests?
Not every project needs board sign-off, but many do when a change affects the exterior, structure, or anything near a boundary line. A simple rule helps: if you can see it from the street or it touches building systems, it likely belongs in the review queue.
Before looking at examples, set the expectation that HOA approval is separate from city or county permitting. One does not replace the other, and homeowners often need both.
Here are common projects that typically require approval:
- Home additions or extensions
- New exterior paint or cladding
- Roof replacements or re-roofs
- Window or door style changes
- Fences, gates, and walls
- Major landscaping redesigns, hardscape, or retaining walls
- Driveway widening or new materials
- Sheds, pergolas, or detached structures
- Solar panels, battery storage, or EV charging equipment
Associations should list these items in the CC&Rs and in easy-to-read architectural standards. In California, it helps to reference Civil Code §4765, which outlines timelines, decision requirements, and what a proper notice should include.
How to Handle Architectural Requests
Not sure if you’re properly managing your HOA architectural requests? Here are some tips that you can follow:
1. Make the Guidelines Clear and Easy To Find
Vague rules cause confusion and delays. Clear standards tell homeowners what they can do and how to ask.
Include design criteria like approved roof types, paint palettes, fence heights, and landscape themes. Post the document on the website, link it in welcome packets, and reshare it before peak renovation months.
2. Explain What Does Not Need Approval
Owners appreciate knowing where they can act without a committee vote. This reduces unnecessary applications and speeds up simple work.
Interior-only projects, such as kitchen remodels or flooring, typically fall outside review unless they involve the exterior. Replacing a dead plant with the same variety or making a minor repair with matching materials usually qualifies, too.
3. Standardize the Application
A consistent form reduces guesswork and keeps reviews focused. It also helps new volunteers come up to speed quickly.
Ask for the owner’s contact details, the property address, a plain-language project description, drawings or sketches, material and color samples, and an estimated timeline. If your policy requires neighbor acknowledgment, please attach the relevant page to the packet.
4. Keep the Submission Process Straightforward
If the path is confusing, people cut corners. A simple online portal or a single email inbox keeps things tidy.
Publish submission cut-off times for each meeting. Send a quick receipt that lists what you got and what is still missing, and add a short note on what happens next.
5. Respond Within a Reasonable Timeframe
Timely answers build trust. In California, associations generally have 45 days from receipt of a complete application to decide.
Track the clock from the date the application becomes complete. If a delay is unavoidable, let the owner know early and provide a new target date.
6. Provide Clear, Written Decisions
A written decision protects both the owner and the association. It should be plain and specific.
State whether the request is approved, conditionally approved, or denied. Cite the relevant sections, list any conditions, include a completion deadline, and identify a contact for questions.
7. Be Consistent With Approvals and Denials
Inconsistent outcomes create friction. Owners compare notes, and perceptions of unfairness spread fast.
Use your written standards as the north star. If you grant an exception, document the special circumstances so future committees understand the reasoning.
8. Document Everything
Good records are about clarity, not red tape. They also help a future board understand past choices.
Keep the application, emails, site notes, meeting minutes showing the vote, and the final letter. Use a simple file naming system so anyone can find documents quickly.
9. Educate Homeowners Early and Often
Education reduces friction and incomplete packets. It also lowers the number of repeat questions to the office.
Share reminders in newsletters, on your website, and at annual meetings. Show photos of approved projects with exact colors and materials so owners can picture success.
10. Know the Role of the Architectural Review Committee
The Architectural Review Committee (ARC) handles technical review so the board can focus on policy. Clear roles keep decisions clean and defensible.
Create a brief charter that defines scope, quorum, voting, and when items must go to the board. Review ARC outcomes periodically to confirm alignment with the standards.
11. Train Architectural Review Committee Members
Volunteers bring energy, but they need tools. Short, focused training pays for itself in better decisions.
Give each member the CC&Rs, standards, and a quick guide for reading plans and elevations. Walk through a few real examples, including a conditional approval and a denial, and explain how to write reasons.
12. Use Professional Help When Needed
Some HOA architectural requests raise technical or legal questions. That is when experts save time and prevent disputes.
Consult an engineer, architect, or surveyor for structural, grading, or boundary issues. Ask counsel about tricky enforcement or interpretation questions, and coordinate with permitting agencies where required.
13. Enforce the Rules Fairly
Approval is not the finish line. The work should match the approved plans.
If field conditions require a change, have the owner submit a quick addendum. When deviations appear, start with a friendly notice, invite a correction, and follow your due process if fines are allowed.
14. Monitor the Work After Approval
After approving HOA architectural reviews, a brief follow-up ensures the need for revisions is closed. It also prevents small deviations from becoming bigger problems.
Schedule a final look when the project wraps. If something is off, explain the issue, allow time to fix it, and then confirm completion in writing.
15. Plan for High Volume Seasons
Spring and summer bring more exterior projects. Planning now avoids bottlenecks later.
Set submission cut-offs for each meeting so owners know which agenda they will hit. Add a special meeting in peak months if the queue grows, and consider fast-tracking safety or weather-sensitive items.
Bonus Tip: Review and Update Guidelines Periodically
Neighborhoods evolve, and building technology changes. Your standards should keep up.
Plan a review every three to five years. Survey owners should gather feedback, check nearby communities for trends, and confirm compliance with current law before adopting updates.
Practical Extras That Make Life Easier
Small tweaks can remove common pain points. These quick wins are simple to roll out and save time for everyone.
Here are practical add-ons you can adopt right away:
- Use plain language and define technical terms in a short glossary.
- Offer pre-approved options for paint palettes, fence styles, and mailboxes.
- Create a small-project track for like-for-like swaps that meet the listed criteria.
- Coordinate with permits and clarify that HOA approval and public licenses are separate.
- Mark the date an application becomes complete to manage the 45-day clock.
- Set reasonable construction hours and publish them alongside noise rules.
- Keep before-and-after photos in the property file for future reference.
A Friendly Walkthrough of the Typical Journey
Owners feel better when they know the road ahead. This quick scenario shows how a well-run review looks from start to finish.
Follow this simple five-step flow:
- Pre-application chat. An owner asks whether a cedar fence is allowed. Management replies with the guidelines, application, and a reminder about height and setback rules.
- Submission. The owner sends the form, a sketch of the fence line, material specs, and neighbor acknowledgments. Management confirms receipt and notes the meeting date.
- Review. The ARC checks height, materials, and easements. A neighbor asks about a trellis, so the ARC adds a condition to keep a three-foot clearance.
- Decision. Within the required window, the HOA sends a conditional approval with cited sections and a completion deadline. The owner understands the conditions and schedules the contractor.
- Construction and closeout. The fence is erected, management conducts a quick inspection, and a completion letter is filed with photos.
Some Frequently Asked Questions:
What if the HOA Misses the Decision Deadline?
In California, a request may be deemed approved if no decision is issued within the timeline after the application becomes complete. Track completeness dates and keep meeting calendars consistent.
Do Permits Replace HOA Approval?
No. Public permits and HOA approvals are separate processes. Owners often need both.
What if a Homeowner Skips Approval?
Follow your notice and hearing steps as outlined in your documents. Offer a path to cure the violation before you consider fines or legal action.
Can the ARC approve between meetings?
Only if your governing documents allow it, if you use a between-meeting process for minor items, record the decision and ratify it at the next meeting.
Fair and Proper Management
Architectural review is about listening, applying clear rules, and guiding owners toward projects that fit the community. When boards communicate well, make timely decisions, and document their reasoning, they build trust and reduce conflict.
Looking for professional support for managing architectural requests? Personalized Property Management offers HOA management services around Southern California. Call us at 760-325-9500 or email us at info@ppminternet.com for more information!
Related Articles: